Bats in the Belfry: An Introduction to Gothic Rock
By Sebastian Serr

Goth! This word, along with its adjectival form, “gothic,” conjures up a variety of images. It denotes a historic ethnic group, a style of architecture, a text font, a literary category, and a type of moth. That’s a lot of things, yet when I say the word “goth,” the first thing that comes to mind is probably something very different. Dyed black hair full of hairspray, white face makeup with black eyeliner, black clothing drawing on stylings from yesteryear, all paired with silver and black jewelry. That is what comes to my head first, and I’m sure I’m not the only one. This idea of what a goth is is rather ubiquitous. You see it in books, movies, cartoons, the lot. But why? Where does this image come from?
Well, rather unsurprisingly, this depiction comes from the Gothic subculture, which formed in Britain in the 1980s and is known for its dark sound and macabre subjects. Gothic rock took the fracturing rock sounds that arose in the wake of British punk rock and paired them with the dark, esoteric, and occasionally salacious themes of Gothic literature.
I’ve always had a connection to gothic rock — my first concert was Bauhaus when I was seven months old. I find the genre fascinating. Over the last year, while doing some deeper dives into the catalog of gothic rock, I’ve found myself wanting to share this passion with other people. And thus, here we are. If you want to learn more about gothic rock, this is the place for you. I will start this series by familiarizing you with the albums and singles that I feel are essential to understanding gothic rock, especially its appeal to a more general audience. So get your boots on and eye shadow ready as we enter this belfry.
Siouxsie and the Banshees - Juju (1981)
When it comes to gothic rock, no band should come before Siouxsie and the Banshees. They, more so than any other band, defined what the gothic subculture would look like. Without frontwoman Siouxsie Sioux and her radical fashion and makeup choices, which at times incorporated heavy eye makeup, fetish gear, and an impressive amount of hairspray, modern goths would be unrecognizable. And that is not even mentioning their musical influence, spanning back to 1978 with The Scream. However, Juju may just be their most iconic, and for good reason. Juju is a must for any fan of rock music, gothic or not. Hitting you face-first with the mystical lead single “Spellbound,” this album hooks you and doesn’t let up until the very end. From the infectious, striking guitar and smooth drums on the second single “Arabian Knights” (which has only mildly racist lyrics), to the soft moments with album closer “Voodoo Dolly,” the sound perfectly fits the album’s esoteric vibes. Recent band additions John McGeoch, formerly the guitarist for Magazine, and Budgie, formerly the drummer for the all-female¹ punk band the Slits, have really grown into the band since debuting on Kaleidoscope the previous year. And that is to say nothing about Siouxsie’s incredible vocal performance, which I think peaks on this album with “Night Shift.” I won't pretend this album is perfect. “Halloween” is a fun seasonal novelty, but lacks substance, and “Head Cut” always takes me out of the headspace the rest of this album constructs so carefully. But one fly in the ointment does little to spoil this dark masterpiece. Plain and simple, if you have not heard this album before, it is required listening in order to call yourself a fan of rock music.
Favorite song: “Arabian Knights”
The Cure - Disintegration (1989)
In the late ‘80s, the Cure’s gothic credibility was ebbing away. After a string of three dark, brooding albums in the early 1980s, culminating in 1982 with Pornography, the Cure sought out a brighter, less depressing sound. While I can’t deny my love for singles like “In Between Days,” “Close to Me,” and “Why Can’t I Be You?”² they are much more poppy and upbeat, certainly not what most would consider “goth.” Whether this constituted selling out is debatable. Regardless, this would change with their final record of the decade, Disintegration. When the soft sound of windchimes are abruptly interrupted by the first airy synthesizer note in album opener “Plainsong,” you know you’re in for a special experience. While this album’s sound is not as dark and brooding as their early ‘80s work, it doesn’t have to be. No longer are the Cure angsty young men with one too many vices — instead, they’re seasoned music veterans who have sold millions and toured arenas all over the world. Their emotion doesn’t need to come from anger anymore. As cheesy as it may sound, love is the overwhelming emotion depicted in this album. Frontman Robert Smith’s recent marriage to Mary Poole is definitely a huge contributing factor to the tone of this album. From “Pictures of You” through “Closedown” into the creatively named “Lovesong” and capping off with “Last Dance,” the whole front end of this album feels like one giant love letter from Robert Smith, lamenting that his time on Earth with his lover will be limited. I hope Smith knows that his love will, in fact, live on much longer in this album, one of the most beautiful records of the 1980s. This is not a perfect album — I’m not terribly fond of “Lullaby”³ and the album struggles from a slightly less immersive second half — but that changes nothing. You must listen to Disintegration. Do it for yourself, you won’t regret it.
Favorite song: “Closedown”
The Sisters of Mercy - Floodland (1987)
The Sisters of Mercy are one of the most enduringly popular bands in the gothic rock scene. Hard drumlines, political lyrics, and a booming baritone from the band’s only principal member, lead singer Andrew Eldritch, has secured a legacy that stretches long after their self-imposed hiatus from new music in 1993. Still, to this day, you can find various “goth” artists making new music that imitates the musical style (to varying degrees of quality) that the Sisters of Mercy perfected on Floodland. This record followed a massive upheaval in the bands’ lineup, seeing as every member, save for Eldritch, quit and went on to form a new band that came to be known as the Mission. This left the future of the Sisters of Mercy murky, but after the hiring of American bassist and “goth pin-up girl” Patricia Morrison, they managed to soldier on⁴.
Floodland marks a change in the band's sound. With guitarist Wayne Hussey gone, the band drifted away from a rock sound. Honestly, this album has more sonically in common with the synth-pop music of the day than it does with their contemporary gothic rock bands. Clearly, the people who wanted to make rock music left to form the Mission, leaving Eldritch to pursue whatever direction he pleased. And what he wanted to do was make the greatest set of gothic club songs of the ‘80s. I think it’s impossible to listen to all 11 minutes of “This Corrosion” without feeling a desire to get up and dance. I have similar feelings towards “Lucretia My Reflection.” There’s just something infectious about the beats on this album, even if they aren’t being made on a real drum set. The pair of “Flood I” and “Flood II” are slower-paced, but I think they’re still fun. “Driven Like the Snow” and “Torch” are rather pretty songs, too, but the true emotional center of this album is “1959,” a piano ballad about Eldritch’s childhood in Ely, Cambridgeshire. The only part of this album that I’m not crazy about is the way that politics are presented. I’ve seen “Lucretia My Reflection” held up as a great work of politically righteous gothic rock and I just don’t see it. I find Eldritch’s vague allusions to Cold War era politics fall flat almost 40 years later. Certainly not a misguided political song, but I find German pop songs like Nena’s “99 Luftballons” and Alphaville’s “Forever Young” to be more politically interesting works from the Cold War. Nonetheless, I’ll be dancing along to “Lucretia My Reflection” for many years to come, and I hope after giving this album a listen yourself, you will as well.
Favorite song: “Lucretia My Reflection”
Depeche Mode - Violator (1990)
I think the inclusion of Depeche Mode may be mildly controversial for those of you who are more familiar with the goth community. I have seen people repeatedly litigate what bands are truly considered “goth,” and Depeche Mode is consistently one of the most debated bands. If you understand Depeche Mode to merely be the synth-pop band full of bubbly teens and twentysomethings who hit it big with the dance hit “Just Can’t Get Enough,” then the gothic claims do seem dubious. But Depeche Mode certainly had some gothic bona fides with songs like “Blasphemous Rumours” and “Stripped” coming out of the 1980s, which embed dark subject matters and violent imagery into their still-synthy sound. For me, Violator was what solidified their legacy within the goth scene. The first track, “World in My Eyes,” promises to “take us on a trip,” and, well, “show us the word in my eyes,” and the album absolutely delivers. The eyes we’re seeing through for this album are those of Martin Gore. As songwriter, guitarist, pianist, singer, and androgynous sadomasochist fetishist, Gore wears many hats (and harnesses) for Depeche Mode. When Vince Clarke (later of Erasure) left Depeche Mode following 1982's A Broken Frame, Gore stepped up to replace him as the main songwriter. Much of Depeche Mode’s dark drift is thanks to Gore’s writing. But on Violator, the darkness is palpable and raw, painting a vivid picture of Gore’s headspace at the time. It’s the image of a man in a mutually destructive relationship, killing himself with drugs (“Sweetest Perfection” and “Enjoy the Silence”) who is unable to break off the relationship due to a perceived dependence (“Halo”) and who keeps relapsing, despite repeated attempts to come clean (“Policy of Truth”). Ideas of addiction and relationship swirl into one, both of which are understandable interpretations of the music. It’s a portrait of a man broken, but not without hope. “Clean,” the final track on the album, serves as the mellow, subdued end to the album. After “putting an end to it all,” the man is finally clean, and “ready to grasp what’s in [his] own hands.” It’s not celebratory, but rather a firm affirmation of one’s ability to break free of a spiral of addiction and abuse, and come out standing. While not a narrative in a traditional sense, this is what the album means to me. I think everyone should listen and form their own conclusion.
Favorite song: “Halo”
Joy Division - Unknown Pleasures (1979)
Joy Division is one of the most influential bands. Full stop. Seriously, it’s kind of impossible to write an introduction for Unknown Pleasures because the album is just so ubiquitous. Everyone’s already written every opinion in the world about it. It's one of those things where if you like music, I just assume you know what this album is. I mean, a person wearing an Unknown Pleasures t-shirt is just visual shorthand for a (usually pretentious) music enthusiast. With this album, Joy Division single-handedly changed the course of British alternative music away from punk rock and towards a mellower, slower sound. Post-punk, if you will. However, despite its reputation and popularity, I find this album to be middling. The album starts off on the right track with “Disorder.” Powerful, energetic drums from Stephen Morris paired with an excellent bass line from Peter Hook provide an excellent backing to Ian Curtis’s voice. Unlike every other Joy Division song, I think I can feel an emotion other than extreme depression in Curtis’s monotonal voice on this track. And that final section always makes me want to crank my CD player to the loudest setting and sing along, my neighbors be damned. But I immediately hit a wall with the second track, “Day of the Lords.” Not a bad song by any means, but a bit of a step back in pace compared to the blasting force of “Disorder.” For me, the album crashes with “Candidate,” a slow, stripped back affair that allows Curtis’s vocals to take the leading role, which I feel is a task that his voice is not up to do. The only thing I like about the following track, “Insight” is the foley art of a gate opening at the beginning. After a couple more songs that I find tedious, we hit a good run to close the album. “Shadowplay” returns the feeling to my body after the numbness of the preceding tracks. “Wilderness” proves an engaging take down of religion. “Interzone” is the song that comes closest to delivering the frantic energy promised in “Disorder,” and is a nice change of pace with Hook singing lead vocals. Then, we close out with more interesting foley art of glass-shattering on the album closer, “I Remember Nothing.” While I have some misgivings about this album, I would never deign to call it “bad.” Not an album I would listen to every day, but crucial for understanding the history of not only gothic rock, but modern music in general.
Favorite song: “Disorder”
Bauhaus - In the Flat Field (1980)⁵
Bauhaus is probably the most purely goth band of the original gothic rockers. Their oppressively dark sound and macabre lyrics set the stage for what came next, exemplified by their debut studio album In the Flat Field. While I think this album is an important one, In the Flat Field can feel a bit juvenile and unfocused. There is a lack of cohesion through the themes of the tracks, drifting between a mythologically tinged lament of meaningless sex on title track “In the Flat Field,” to a depiction of the crucifixion of Jesus Christ in “Stigmata Martyr,” to a rather comical complaint about small talk in the aptly titled “Small Talk Stinks.” It can feel like Bauhaus is just throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks. But what In the Flat Field lacks in a throughline it makes up for in conviction. Singer Peter Murphy is giving his all in a brooding yet emotional delivery. While I feel that Murphy’s vocal performance for Bauhaus improves in later albums, the raw, unpolished sound is appealing. And I think that rough sound is a large part of this album's overall charm. It’s not slick, it’s not technically pretty, but Bauhaus has this undeniable dark energy that is infectious on this album. Bauhaus is masterful at setting the right mood, evoking dour ambience with just enough brevity to keep the experience from being unhappy. This album just sucks me in. Every listen feels so brief as I’m guided through these forlorn vignettes. In the Flat Field may not be as polished and accessible as the first two albums on this list, but damn, if it is not captivating. A necessary step for understanding this genre.
Favorite song: “A God in an Alcove”

The Cure - “Charlotte Sometimes” (1981)
This is my favorite single from the Cure’s original dark era. While “A Forest” is often sighted as their best from this era, I just can’t get fully behind it. Make no mistake, I love “A Forest,” but I just don’t find the image of trees as evocative as “Charlotte Sometimes.” Released between the underrated Faith and the now critically acclaimed Pornography, I find this song bridges the gap between albums perfectly — beautiful and gossamery like Faith, yet still dark and glum like Pornography. To me, this song has a simultaneous quality of both being timeless and nostalgic, while also being very obviously a child of the ‘80s. It makes me want to actually go out and read Penelope Farmer’s Charlotte Sometimes, the British children’s novel that the song is based on.
Joy Division - “Love Will Tear Us Apart” (1980)
By my money, this is the best song Joy Division ever made. Frontman Ian Curtis’s signature low, unenthused singing voice is exceptional in this encapsulation of ruined love. He pours himself into the song, in the most emotional, yet unemotional performance of his life. I get the impression that the topic of a ruined relationship was something very close at hand for Curtis, given that his wife was filing for divorce after he cheated on her with a Belgian woman. They say write what you know, and Curtis does so very effectively on this song. Paired with an all-time great synth line, I would be shocked if you didn’t already know and love this song.
Bauhaus - “Bela Lugosi’s Dead” (1979)
Ah, the 9 minute long song about some Romania guy that all goths love. Bauhaus’s debut single “Bela Lugosi’s Dead” is in many ways the true starting point of gothic rock. Only slightly predated by Joy Division’s debut album Unknown Pleasures, I think “Bela Lugosi’s Dead” manages to capture the spirit of the gothic subculture much more accurately than any track on Unknown Pleasures. This song is weird, long, and utterly fun. Excellent for dancing in the goth club in your finest nylon fishnets, slept-in makeup, ankh accessories, and platform boots.

Siouxsie and the Banshees - “Kiss Them for Me” (1991)
The inclusion of this song is more of an obligation than anything else. For all of their greatness, this is the only Siouxsie and the Banshees song to chart in the top 40 in the United States. While in the United Kingdom, their debut single, “Hong Kong Garden” cracked the top 10, and their Beatles cover “Dear Prudence” reached number 3, this success did not translate to the American market. But if you ask your parents, they’ll probably vaguely remember “Kiss Them for Me.” It’s a decent song that is very different from their ‘80s work with its more electronic sound and dance energy⁶, but enjoyable nonetheless.
The Boys Next Door - “Shivers” (1979)⁷
While the Boys Next Door would go on to change their name to the Birthday Party, move from their native Australia to England, release their biggest single “Release the Bats” in 1981, then fall apart a few years later and spawn the bane of my existence Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, I think their sophomore single “Shivers” is an impressive song. Written by the legendary Rowland S. Howard and sung by Nick Cave, this song was originally supposed to be a tongue-in-cheek mockery of irrational teenage romance as observed by the then 16-year-old Howard. However, Cave took the song in a very different direction. While I hate to give Nick Cave credit for literally anything, I think this was a good choice. He manages to capture an admirable amount of longing and tragedy in his voice. Overall, this song is Rowland S. Howard at his most accessible and Nick Cave at his most tolerable. Good work from some lads down under.

Echo and the Bunnymen - “The Killing Moon” (1984)
Echo and the Bunnymen are not goth. They just aren’t. I’ve invalidated my “goth cred” by including them here. If the “goths” didn’t already want to string me up by my ankles for ripping into Unknown Pleasures, then this’ll do it. Scouse post-punk band Echo and the Bunnymen are a band that I struggle to categorize: too bright and upbeat for gothic rock, but too artsy and dramatic for me to call them just another new wave pop band. Let me just put it this way — on a scale from Bauhaus to Duran Duran, they’re probably the midpoint. But I feel that their 1984 hit single, “The Killing Moon,” is appropriately morose enough to make the cut for my list. A beautiful string section pairs well with singer Ian McCulloch’s unexpectedly distinct voice. A perfect song for you vampirefolk (who I know read my piece) when you’re biting the jugular of a man under a full moon.
Addendum:
¹Budgie is very definitely a chap, not a chick. No, I don’t know how the drummer for an “all-female” band can be a dude.
²If you ever wanted to see the Cure’s keyboardist, Lol Tolhurst, wear blackface, then this is the music video for you.
³When I say I’m not fond of this song, what I mean is I think it is the worst song on the album. Many people have told me they like this song, including my own father who looked at me funny when I said I didn’t like it. I’m sorry, I just can’t do Robert Smith mumbling for 4 minutes about how the “spider man” is going to eat him. I spend the whole time just thinking “When does ‘Fascination Street’ start?” If you want a creepy song about a fictional monster, I suggest Siouxsie and the Banshees’ “Rawhead and Bloody Bones.” Much stranger and more unnerving than “Lullaby.”
⁴Okay, so there is actually another member of the Sisters of Mercy from this era: the only other principal member besides Eldritch, Doktor Avalanche. Who is Doktor Avalanche? Eldritch’s drum machine. I’m sorry if you feel this is discriminatory against drum machine kind, but I don’t think that’s a real member.
⁵I reviewed the original tracklisting of this album, not the expanded edition. The original tracklisting of this album spans from the songs “Double Dare” to “Nerves.” Also, I just wanted to mention that the cover of this album has a picture from the legendary Duane Michals. If you don't know Duane Michals, you should look up Duane Michals.
⁶This is not to say Siouxsie and the Banshees have not made dance music before this point. “Slowdive,” “Peek-A-Boo,” hell, even “Dazzle,” are all very danceable tracks in their catalog that came before “Kiss Them For Me.” But there’s just something about Superstition as a whole that feels different compared to those older songs. The slick synth paired with those beats makes Siouxsie and the Banshees feel more dance-oriented than ever before. Superstition reminds me more of albums like Pretty Hate Machine than it does The Scream. I guess that’s just bound to happen when you keep innovating with your sound, and that’s one of the reasons Siouxsie and the Banshees are my favorite band. They never stagnated, they were always changing and I think their most experimental and eclectic albums (A Kiss in the Dreamhouse and Peepshow) are their best.
⁷This is just the cover of the album that the single was included on as the single did not have special artwork.
